April 4, 1910

Buck Herzog and 2 others: Atlanta BravesSan Francisco Giants

Atlanta Braves came out ahead by 2.1 WAR, most of it from Buck Herzog.

Atlanta Braves
franchise trade score
88far better
Franchise trade score88
Rest of season94WAR in+2.0WAR out+0.7Net+1.3
Short term95WAR in+4.1WAR out+0.8Net+3.3
Control window87WAR in+4.1WAR out+2.0Net+2.1
Full tenure86WAR in+4.1WAR out+2.0Net+2.1
San Francisco Giants
franchise trade score
12far worse
Franchise trade score12
Rest of season6WAR in+0.7WAR out+2.0Net-1.3
Short term5WAR in+0.8WAR out+4.1Net-3.3
Control window13WAR in+2.0WAR out+4.1Net-2.1
Full tenure14WAR in+2.0WAR out+4.1Net-2.1

SFG reached the World Series in 1911

Atlanta Braves received

Buck Herzog2B · 25 · pre-arb · 8 yrs control+4.3WAR (control) · 2 yr89
Rest of season84WAR+1.6wRC+90PA443
Short term92WAR+4.3wRC+109PA800
Control window88WAR+4.3wRC+109PA800
Full tenure86WAR+4.3wRC+109PA800

scored without value

On the day: +2.1 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 51, salary $3K.

Bill CollinsLF · 28 · pre-arb · 8 yrs control-0.2WAR (control) · 2 yr20
Rest of season68WAR+0.3wRC+71PA660
Short term19WAR-0.2wRC+65PA707
Control window20WAR-0.2wRC+65PA707
Full tenure20WAR-0.2wRC+65PA707

scored without value

San Francisco Giants received

Beals BeckerRF · 24 · pre-arb · 8 yrs control+2.0WAR (control) · 3 yr79
Rest of season88WAR+0.7wRC+127PA145
Short term75WAR+0.8wRC+113PA346
Control window81WAR+2.0wRC+109PA817
Full tenure80WAR+2.0wRC+109PA817

scored without value

On the day: -1.3 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 90.

What this became

  1. Bill Collins → CHCWilbur Good, ATL ⇄ CHC, 1911+0.1 WAR
  2. Buck Herzog → SFGHank Gowdy, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1911+6.4 WAR
  3. Cliff Curtis → PHICliff Curtis, CHC ⇄ PHI, 1911+0.5 WAR
  4. Peaches Graham → PHIDick Cotter, CHC ⇄ PHI, 1912-0.1 WAR
  5. Johnny Kling → CINTex McDonald, ATL ⇄ CIN, 1913+1.0 WAR
  6. Buck Herzog → CINBuck Herzog, CIN ⇄ SFG, 1913+11.4 WAR
  7. Hank Gowdy → SFGJesse Barnes, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1923+4.6 WAR
  8. Bob Bescher → STLPol Perritt, SFG ⇄ STL, 1915+3.1 WAR
  9. Buck Herzog → SFGEdd Roush, CIN ⇄ SFG, 1916+3.4 WAR
  10. Jesse Barnes → LADEddie Brown, ATL ⇄ LAD, 1925+0.0 WAR
  11. Buck Herzog → ATLJesse Barnes, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1918+0.4 WAR
  12. Edd Roush → SFGGeorge Kelly, CIN ⇄ SFG, 1927+3.1 WAR
  13. Zack Taylor → SFGLarry Benton, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1927-0.4 WAR

The web around this trade

loading the web…
player · size = WAR delivered, colour = percentile ( worse better) franchise trade 0 players · 0 trades · 0 clubs
All ATL ⇄ SFG tradesHow the scores work