July 20, 1916

Edd Roush and 4 others: Cincinnati RedsSan Francisco Giants

Cincinnati Reds got 32.8 WAR out of Edd Roush over 8 seasons. San Francisco Giants got 3.5 from the whole return.

Cincinnati Reds
franchise trade score
99far better
Franchise trade score99
Rest of season88WAR in+2.6WAR out+1.9Net+0.7
Short term96WAR in+7.6WAR out+3.5Net+4.1
Control window100WAR in+33.1WAR out+3.5Net+29.6
Full tenure100WAR in+42.3WAR out+3.5Net+38.8

CIN won the World Series in 1919

San Francisco Giants
franchise trade score
1far worse
Franchise trade score1
Rest of season12WAR in+1.9WAR out+2.6Net-0.7
Short term4WAR in+3.5WAR out+7.6Net-4.1
Control window0WAR in+3.5WAR out+33.1Net-29.6
Full tenure0WAR in+3.5WAR out+42.3Net-38.8

Cincinnati Reds received

Christy MathewsonP · 36 · FA eligible · 8 yrs control+0.0WAR (control) · 1 yr52
Rest of season72WAR+0.0FIP−130IP9
Short term54WAR+0.0FIP−130IP9
Control window51WAR+0.0FIP−130IP9
Full tenure51WAR+0.0FIP−130IP9

too little playing time to rate quality; scored without value

On the day: +8.0 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 64, FIP− 103.

Edd RoushCF · 23 · arb 1 · 8 yrs control+32.8WAR (control) · 8 yr99
Rest of season96WAR+2.3wRC+127PA300
Short term99WAR+7.2wRC+144PA867
Control window100WAR+32.8wRC+146PA3824
Full tenure100WAR+42.0wRC+141PA5563

scored without value

On the day: +4.4 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 119, salary $5K.

Bill McKechnie3B · 30 · FA eligible · 8 yrs control+0.3WAR (control) · 2 yr54
Rest of season68WAR+0.2wRC+79PA141
Short term56WAR+0.3wRC+80PA286
Control window53WAR+0.3wRC+80PA286
Full tenure53WAR+0.3wRC+80PA286

scored without value

On the day: +4.7 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 93, salary $3K.

San Francisco Giants received

Buck Herzog2B · 31 · FA eligible · 8 yrs control+3.4WAR (control) · 2 yr84
Rest of season90WAR+1.8wRC+105PA320
Short term87WAR+3.4wRC+100PA797
Control window83WAR+3.4wRC+100PA797
Full tenure82WAR+3.4wRC+100PA797

scored without value

On the day: +13.0 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 93, salary $10K.

Red KilleferLF · 31 · FA eligible · 8 yrs control+0.1WAR (control) · 1 yr54
Rest of season74WAR+0.1wRC+452PA2
Short term56WAR+0.1wRC+452PA2
Control window53WAR+0.1wRC+452PA2
Full tenure53WAR+0.1wRC+452PA2

too little playing time to rate quality; scored without value

On the day: +5.5 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 112.

What this became

  1. Buck Herzog → ATLJesse Barnes, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1918+0.4 WAR
  2. Edd Roush → SFGGeorge Kelly, CIN ⇄ SFG, 1927+3.1 WAR
  3. Buck Herzog → CHCLes Mann, ATL ⇄ CHC, 1919-0.1 WAR
  4. Jesse Barnes → ATLJesse Barnes, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1923+8.3 WAR
  5. Jesse Barnes → LADEddie Brown, ATL ⇄ LAD, 1925+0.0 WAR
  6. Zack Taylor → SFGLarry Benton, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1927-0.4 WAR

The web around this trade

loading the web…
player · size = WAR delivered, colour = percentile ( worse better) franchise trade 0 players · 0 trades · 0 clubs
All CIN ⇄ SFG tradesHow the scores work