December 4, 1957

Early Wynn and 3 others: Chicago White SoxCleveland Guardians

Chicago White Sox came out ahead by 13.1 WAR, most of it from Early Wynn.

Chicago White Sox
franchise trade score
85far better
Franchise trade score85
Rest of season50WAR in0.0WAR out0.0Net0.0
Short term10WAR in+2.7WAR out+4.7Net-2.0
Control window98WAR in+23.2WAR out+10.1Net+13.1
Full tenure97WAR in+23.2WAR out+10.1Net+13.1

CHW reached the World Series in 1959

Cleveland Guardians
franchise trade score
15far worse
Franchise trade score15
Rest of season50WAR in0.0WAR out0.0Net0.0
Short term90WAR in+4.7WAR out+2.7Net+2.0
Control window2WAR in+10.1WAR out+23.2Net-13.1
Full tenure3WAR in+10.1WAR out+23.2Net-13.1

Chicago White Sox received

Early WynnP · 37 · FA eligible · 8 yrs control+13.0WAR (control) · 5 yr87
Rest of season45WAR0.0FIP−IP0
Short term80WAR+2.0FIP−102IP240
Control window91WAR+13.0FIP−98IP1011
Full tenure90WAR+13.0FIP−98IP1011

scored without value

On the day: +18.3 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 55, FIP− 79.

Al SmithRF · 29 · arb 2 · 8 yrs control+10.2WAR (control) · 5 yr88
Rest of season45WAR0.0wRC+PA0
Short term69WAR+0.7wRC+99PA541
Control window94WAR+10.2wRC+114PA2843
Full tenure94WAR+10.2wRC+114PA2843

scored without value

On the day: +10.5 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 114, salary $15K.

Cleveland Guardians received

Minnie MiñosoLF · 34 · FA eligible · 8 yrs control+10.4WAR (control) · 2 yr97
Rest of season45WAR0.0wRC+PA0
Short term97WAR+5.0wRC+142PA638
Control window97WAR+10.4wRC+139PA1288
Full tenure96WAR+10.4wRC+139PA1288

scored without value

On the day: +17.6 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 150.

Fred Hatfield3B · 32 · FA eligible · 8 yrs control-0.3WAR (control) · 1 yr16
Rest of season45WAR0.0wRC+PA0
Short term15WAR-0.3wRC+3PA9
Control window16WAR-0.3wRC+3PA9
Full tenure16WAR-0.3wRC+3PA9

too little playing time to rate quality; scored without value

On the day: +4.0 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 91.

What this became

  1. Fred Hatfield → CINCIN ⇄ CLE, 1958-0.0 WAR
  2. Minnie Miñoso → CHWJohn Romano, CHW ⇄ CLE, 1959+4.6 WAR
  3. Al Smith → BALPete Ward, BAL ⇄ CHW, 1963+0.9 WAR
  4. Norm Cash → DETNorm Cash, CLE ⇄ DET, 1960+36.9 WAR
  5. Minnie Miñoso → STLJoe Cunningham, CHW ⇄ STL, 1961-0.3 WAR
  6. Bubba Phillips → DETGordon Seyfried, CLE ⇄ DET, 1962-0.8 WAR
  7. Al Smith → CLEWillie Kirkland, BAL ⇄ CLE, 1963-0.9 WAR
  8. John Romano → CHWTommy John, CHW ⇄ CLE ⇄ OAK, 1965+5.5 WAR
  9. Dave Nicholson → HOUBill Heath, CHW ⇄ HOU, 1965+0.8 WAR
  10. Luis Aparicio → CHWDon Buford, BAL ⇄ CHW, 1967+12.5 WAR
  11. Ron Hansen → TEXRon Hansen, CHW ⇄ TEX, 1968+1.0 WAR
  12. Pete Ward → NYYPete Ward, CHW ⇄ NYY, 1969+0.3 WAR
  13. Joe Cunningham → TEXBill Skowron, CHW ⇄ TEX, 1964+0.2 WAR
  14. Jim Landis → CLEJoe Rudi, CLE ⇄ OAK, 1965+0.1 WAR
  15. Cam Carreon → BALCam Carreon, BAL ⇄ CLE, 1966+0.2 WAR
  16. Fred Talbot → NYYRoger Repoz, NYY ⇄ OAK, 1966-0.1 WAR
  17. John Romano → STLWalt Williams, CHW ⇄ STL, 1966-0.3 WAR
  18. Dave Nicholson → ATLEddie Mathews, ATL ⇄ HOU, 1966-0.4 WAR
  19. Rocky Colavito → CHWRocky Colavito, CHW ⇄ CLE, 1967+0.0 WAR
  20. Tommie Agee → NYMTommie Agee, CHW ⇄ NYM, 1967+14.4 WAR
  21. Russ Snyder → CLERuss Snyder, CHW ⇄ CLE, 1968+0.2 WAR
  22. Bruce Howard → TEXBAL ⇄ TEX, 1968-0.8 WAR
  23. Tim Cullen → TEXTim Cullen, CHW ⇄ TEX, 1968+1.0 WAR
  24. Bob Priddy → LAASandy Alomar, CHW ⇄ LAA, 1969-0.1 WAR
  25. Dennis Higgins → CLEDave Nelson, CLE ⇄ TEX, 1969+0.7 WAR
  26. Mickey Scott → BALMickey Scott, BAL ⇄ CHW, 1970+0.1 WAR
  27. John Matias → KCRPat Kelly, CHW ⇄ KCR, 19700.0 WAR
  28. Luis Aparicio → BOSLuis Aparicio, BOS ⇄ CHW, 1970+3.4 WAR
  29. Tommy John → LADTommy John, CHW ⇄ LAD, 1971+18.2 WAR
  30. Jim Landis → HOULee Maye, CLE ⇄ HOU, 1967+0.0 WAR
  31. Sandy Alomar → NYMHOU ⇄ NYM, 1967-0.4 WAR
  32. Bill Skowron → LAACHW ⇄ LAA, 1967-0.7 WAR
  33. Roger Repoz → LAARoger Repoz, LAA ⇄ OAK, 1967+5.4 WAR
  34. Jack Fisher → CINDon Pavletich, CHW ⇄ CIN, 1968-0.7 WAR
  35. Eddie Mathews → DETEddie Mathews, DET ⇄ HOU, 1967+1.1 WAR
  36. Frank Kreutzer → PITJim Shellenback, PIT ⇄ TEX, 19690.0 WAR
  37. Fred Talbot → MILJack Aker, MIL ⇄ NYY, 1969+1.4 WAR
  38. Bob Priddy → ATLMickey Rivers, ATL ⇄ LAA, 1969-0.7 WAR
  39. Phil Roof → MILKen Sanders, MIL ⇄ OAK, 1970+1.5 WAR
  40. Russ Snyder → MILRoy Foster, CLE ⇄ MIL, 1970-1.5 WAR
  41. Barry Moore → CHWBuddy Bradford, CHW ⇄ CLE, 1970-0.7 WAR
  42. Billy Wynne → LAATom Bradley, CHW ⇄ LAA, 1970+0.1 WAR
  43. Bobby Knoop → KCRCHW ⇄ KCR, 1971-0.8 WAR
  44. Walt Williams → CLEWalt Williams, CHW ⇄ CLE, 1972+1.0 WAR
  45. Tommie Agee → HOUTommie Agee, HOU ⇄ NYM, 1972+0.6 WAR
  46. Horacio Piña → OAKHoracio Piña, OAK ⇄ TEX, 1972+0.1 WAR
  47. Jim Rittwage → STLCLE ⇄ STL, 19730.0 WAR
  48. Luis Alvarado → STLCHW ⇄ STL, 1974-0.1 WAR
  49. Mickey Scott → LAABAL ⇄ LAA, 1974-0.3 WAR
  50. Dick Allen → ATLJim Essian, ATL ⇄ CHW, 19740.0 WAR
  51. Dave Nelson → KCRNelson Briles, KCR ⇄ TEX, 1975-0.1 WAR
  52. Pat Kelly → BALPat Kelly, BAL ⇄ CHW, 1976+0.7 WAR

The web around this trade

loading the web…
player · size = WAR delivered, colour = percentile ( worse better) franchise trade 0 players · 0 trades · 0 clubs
All CHW ⇄ CLE tradesHow the scores work