December 5, 1957

Curt Flood and 4 others: Cincinnati RedsSt. Louis Cardinals

St. Louis Cardinals got 24.5 WAR out of Curt Flood over 8 seasons. Cincinnati Reds got 1.2 from the whole return.

Cincinnati Reds
franchise trade score
2far worse
Franchise trade score2
Rest of season50WAR in0.0WAR out0.0Net0.0
Short term9WAR in+0.7WAR out+2.9Net-2.2
Control window1WAR in+1.2WAR out+24.8Net-23.6
Full tenure0WAR in+1.2WAR out+39.6Net-38.4
St. Louis Cardinals
franchise trade score
98far better
Franchise trade score98
Rest of season50WAR in0.0WAR out0.0Net0.0
Short term91WAR in+2.9WAR out+0.7Net+2.2
Control window99WAR in+24.8WAR out+1.2Net+23.6
Full tenure100WAR in+39.6WAR out+1.2Net+38.4

STL won the World Series in 1964

Cincinnati Reds received

Marty KutynaP · 25 · prospect · 8 yrs control0.0WAR (control)40
Rest of season45WAR0.0FIP−—IP0
Short term41WAR0.0FIP−—IP0
Control window40WAR0.0FIP−—IP0
Full tenure40WAR0.0FIP−—IP0

never reached the majors for CIN; scored without value

Ted WieandP · 24 · prospect · 8 yrs control-0.4WAR (control) · 2 yr18
Rest of season45WAR0.0FIP−—IP0
Short term27WAR-0.1FIP−170IP2
Control window13WAR-0.4FIP−244IP6
Full tenure14WAR-0.4FIP−244IP6

too little playing time to rate quality; scored without value

Willard SchmidtP · 29 · arb 2 · 8 yrs control+1.6WAR (control) · 2 yr76
Rest of season45WAR0.0FIP−—IP0
Short term69WAR+0.7FIP−104IP69
Control window77WAR+1.6FIP−95IP140
Full tenure76WAR+1.6FIP−95IP140

scored without value

On the day: +5.8 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 39, FIP− 123.

St. Louis Cardinals received

Curt FloodCF · 19 · pre-arb · 8 yrs control+24.5WAR (control) · 8 yr90
Rest of season45WAR0.0wRC+—PA0
Short term78WAR+2.6wRC+84PA461
Control window92WAR+24.5wRC+100PA4346
Full tenure94WAR+39.3wRC+102PA6913

scored without value

On the day: -0.2 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ -100.

Joe TaylorOF · 31 · pre-arb · 8 yrs control+0.3WAR (control) · 1 yr61
Rest of season45WAR0.0wRC+—PA0
Short term63WAR+0.3wRC+130PA27
Control window60WAR+0.3wRC+130PA27
Full tenure59WAR+0.3wRC+130PA27

too little playing time to rate quality; scored without value

On the day: -1.5 WAR over the prior three seasons.

What this became

  1. Marty Kutyna → OAKMarty Kutyna, CIN ⇄ OAK, 1959+0.4 WAR
  2. Ted Wieand → NYYLuis Arroyo, CIN ⇄ NYY, 19600.0 WAR
  3. Curt Flood → PHIWillie Montañez, PHI ⇄ STL, 19690.0 WAR
  4. Marty Kutyna → TEXMarty Kutyna, OAK ⇄ TEX, 1960+0.6 WAR
  5. Jesse Gonder → CINJesse Gonder, CIN ⇄ NYY, 1961+0.2 WAR
  6. Jerry Johnson → SFGFrank Linzy, SFG ⇄ STL, 1970-0.1 WAR
  7. Cookie Rojas → KCRCookie Rojas, KCR ⇄ STL, 1970+6.7 WAR
  8. Dick Allen → LADTed Sizemore, LAD ⇄ STL, 1970+5.3 WAR
  9. Curt Flood → TEXJeff Terpko, PHI ⇄ TEX, 1970-0.4 WAR
  10. Tim McCarver → WSNTim McCarver, PHI ⇄ WSN, 1972+0.5 WAR
  11. Joe Hoerner → ATLATL ⇄ PHI, 1972-0.7 WAR
  12. Byron Browne → STLPHI ⇄ STL, 19720.0 WAR
  13. Willie Montañez → SFGGarry Maddox, PHI ⇄ SFG, 1975+1.7 WAR
  14. Jesse Gonder → NYMJesse Gonder, CIN ⇄ NYM, 1963+1.9 WAR
  15. Fred Rico → MINStan Williams, MIN ⇄ STL, 19710.0 WAR
  16. Bob Stinson → HOUMarty Martínez, HOU ⇄ STL, 1971-0.5 WAR
  17. Dick Allen → CHWTommy John, CHW ⇄ LAD, 1971+15.4 WAR
  18. Frank Linzy → MILMIL ⇄ STL, 1972-0.6 WAR
  19. Tim McCarver → STLTim McCarver, STL ⇄ WSN, 1972+0.1 WAR
  20. Andre Thornton → CHCAndre Thornton, ATL ⇄ CHC, 1973+5.1 WAR
  21. Ted Sizemore → LADWillie Crawford, LAD ⇄ STL, 1976+0.2 WAR
  22. Willie Montañez → ATLDarrell Evans, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1976+0.3 WAR
  23. Jeff Terpko → WSNTEX ⇄ WSN, 1977-0.3 WAR
  24. Sammy Taylor → CLESammy Taylor, CIN ⇄ CLE, 1963+0.1 WAR
  25. Jesse Gonder → ATLATL ⇄ NYM, 1965-0.1 WAR
  26. Marty Martínez → OAKOAK ⇄ STL, 1972-0.5 WAR
  27. Frank Linzy → PHIFrank Linzy, MIL ⇄ PHI, 1973+0.2 WAR
  28. Dick Allen → ATLJim Essian, ATL ⇄ CHW, 19740.0 WAR
  29. Andre Thornton → WSNSteve Renko, CHC ⇄ WSN, 1976-0.0 WAR
  30. Willie Crawford → SFGDave Rader, SFG ⇄ STL, 19760.0 WAR
  31. Ted Sizemore → PHITed Sizemore, LAD ⇄ PHI, 1976+1.4 WAR
  32. Marty Perez → NYYTerry Whitfield, NYY ⇄ SFG, 1977+0.0 WAR
  33. Rodney Scott → OAKClaudell Washington, OAK ⇄ TEX, 1977+0.5 WAR
  34. Willie Montañez → NYMJon Matlack, ATL ⇄ NYM ⇄ PIT ⇄ TEX, 1977+0.7 WAR

Also that day

Bob Rush, ATL ⇄ CHC, 1957Atlanta Braves ⇄ Chicago Cubs

The web around this trade

loading the web…
player · size = WAR delivered, colour = percentile ( worse better) franchise trade 0 players · 0 trades · 0 clubs
All CIN ⇄ STL tradesHow the scores work