head to head

New York Yankees ⇄ St. Louis Cardinals

12 trades · by score, NYY came out ahead in 6 of 12. Flip · NYY · STL

Jordan Montgomery and 1 other2022
7NYY93STL

St. Louis Cardinals came out ahead by 2.5 WAR, most of it from Jordan Montgomery.

Giovanny Gallegos and 3 others2018
70NYY30STL

Giovanny Gallegos stayed 6 seasons and was the best of it, and it still came out close to even.

Sterling Hitchcock and 2 others2003
63NYY37STL

Sterling Hitchcock changed clubs, and none of them amounted to much for either side.

Lee Smith and 1 other1993
51NYY49STL

Rich Batchelor and Lee Smith changed clubs, and neither amounted to much for either side.

Bob Meacham and 4 others1982
87NYY13STL

New York Yankees came out ahead by 2.9 WAR, most of it from Bob Meacham.

Willie McGee and 1 other1981
3NYY97STL

St. Louis Cardinals got 18.0 WAR out of Willie McGee over 6 seasons. New York Yankees got 0.0 from the whole return.

George Frazier and 1 other1981
91NYY9STL

New York Yankees came out ahead by 3.8 WAR, most of it from George Frazier.

Wayne Granger and 2 others1973
59NYY41STL

Cash considerations is the whole of what changed hands besides Wayne Granger.

Roger Maris and 1 other1966
9NYY91STL

St. Louis Cardinals came out ahead by 4.0 WAR, most of it from Roger Maris.

Trade · 2 players1961
50NYY50STL

Frank Leja changed clubs, and none of them amounted to much for either side.

Bill Virdon and 3 others1954
29NYY71STL

Close to a wash — the margin never reached a full win.

Billy Johnson and 2 others1951
9NYY91STL

$15,000 is the whole of what changed hands besides Billy Johnson.