January 15, 2018 · Cash considerations

Bryan Reynolds and 3 others: Pittsburgh PiratesSan Francisco Giants

Pittsburgh Pirates got 18.5 WAR out of Bryan Reynolds over 6 seasons. San Francisco Giants got 1.5 from the whole return.

Pittsburgh Pirates

franchise trade score

99far better

Franchise trade score99

Rest of season71WAR in+1.2WAR out+1.5Net-0.3Net surplus$11.0M

Short term98WAR in+4.7WAR out+1.5Net+3.2Net surplus$42.1M

Control window99WAR in+19.2WAR out+1.5Net+17.8Net surplus$127.4M

Full tenure99WAR in+23.5WAR out+1.5Net+22.0Net surplus$138.7M

San Francisco Giants

franchise trade score

1far worse

Franchise trade score1

Rest of season29WAR in+1.5WAR out+1.2Net+0.3Net surplus−$11.0M

Short term2WAR in+1.5WAR out+4.7Net-3.2Net surplus−$42.1M

Control window1WAR in+1.5WAR out+19.2Net-17.8Net surplus−$127.4M

Full tenure1WAR in+1.5WAR out+23.5Net-22.0Net surplus−$138.7M

Pittsburgh Pirates received

Kyle CrickP · 26 · pre-arb · 6 yrs control+0.7WAR (control) · 4 yr73

Rest of season93WAR+1.2FIP−78IP60Surplus$8.7M

Short term75WAR+0.8FIP−103IP109Surplus$5.8M

Control window72WAR+0.7FIP−102IP139Surplus$4.3M

Full tenure71WAR+0.7FIP−102IP139Surplus$4.3M

On the day: +0.9 WAR over the prior three seasons, FIP− 96.

Bryan ReynoldsLF · 23 · prospect · 6 yrs control+18.5WAR (control) · 6 yr97

Rest of season47WAR0.0wRC+—PA0Surplus$0.0M

Short term96WAR+4.0wRC+130PA546Surplus$34.0M

Control window98WAR+18.5wRC+120PA3346Surplus$120.7M

Full tenure98WAR+22.8wRC+117PA4640Surplus$132.0M

Player to be named later—WAR (control)—

Not rated — never reached the majors.

Received	Status	Salary that year	Paid	WAR	$/WAR	Surplus
Kyle Crick	pre-arb	est.	$2.5M	+0.7	$3.5M	$4.3M
Bryan Reynolds	prospect	est.	$25.8M	+18.5	$1.4M	$120.7M
Total over the control window			$28.3M	+19.2	$1.5M	$125.1M

San Francisco Giants received

Andrew McCutchenDH · 32 · signed (FA) · 1 yr control+1.5WAR (control) · 1 yr64

Rest of season70WAR+1.5wRC+115PA568Surplus−$2.3M

Short term65WAR+1.5wRC+115PA568Surplus−$2.3M

Control window63WAR+1.5wRC+115PA568Surplus−$2.3M

Full tenure63WAR+1.5wRC+115PA568Surplus−$2.3M

On the day: +8.5 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 122, salary $14.8M.

Cash—WAR (control)—

Not rated — cash.

Received	Status	Salary that year	Paid	WAR	$/WAR	Surplus
Andrew McCutchen	signed (FA)	$14.8M	$13.5M	+1.5	$9.1M	−$2.3M
Total over the control window			$13.5M	+1.5	$9.1M	−$2.3M

What this became

Andrew McCutchen → NYYAndrew McCutchen, NYY ⇄ SFG, 2018+0.8 WAR

The web around this trade

loading the web…

player · size = WAR delivered, colour = percentile ( worse better) franchise trade 0 players · 0 trades · 0 clubs

All PIT ⇄ SFG trades How the scores work