December 18, 1995

Miguel Cairo and 3 others: Seattle MarinersToronto Blue Jays

Paul Menhart, Edwin Hurtado and Miguel Cairo changed clubs among others, and none of them amounted to much for either side.

Seattle Mariners

franchise trade score

26worse

Franchise trade score26

Rest of season50WAR in0.0WAR out0.0Net0.0Net surplus$0.0M

Short term21WAR in-1.2WAR out+0.2Net-1.4Net surplus−$1.6M

Control window26WAR in-1.8WAR out-0.3Net-1.4Net surplus−$1.1M

Full tenure27WAR in-1.8WAR out-0.3Net-1.4Net surplus−$1.1M

Toronto Blue Jays

franchise trade score

74better

Franchise trade score74

Rest of season50WAR in0.0WAR out0.0Net0.0Net surplus$0.0M

Short term79WAR in+0.2WAR out-1.2Net+1.4Net surplus$1.6M

Control window74WAR in-0.3WAR out-1.8Net+1.4Net surplus$1.1M

Full tenure73WAR in-0.3WAR out-1.8Net+1.4Net surplus$1.1M

Seattle Mariners received

Paul MenhartP · 26 · pre-arb · 6 yrs control-0.6WAR (control) · 1 yr14

Rest of season47WAR0.0FIP−—IP0Surplus$0.0M

Short term13WAR-0.6FIP−141IP42Surplus−$0.8M

Control window14WAR-0.6FIP−141IP42Surplus−$0.8M

Full tenure15WAR-0.6FIP−141IP42Surplus−$0.8M

On the day: no major-league record, salary $109K.

Edwin HurtadoP · 25 · pre-arb · 6 yrs control-1.2WAR (control) · 2 yr8

Rest of season47WAR0.0FIP−—IP0Surplus$0.0M

Short term13WAR-0.6FIP−126IP48Surplus−$0.9M

Control window7WAR-1.2FIP−141IP67Surplus−$1.8M

Full tenure8WAR-1.2FIP−141IP67Surplus−$1.8M

On the day: no major-league record, salary $109K.

Received	Status	Salary that year	Paid	WAR	$/WAR	Surplus
Paul Menhart	pre-arb	$109K	$0.1M	-0.6	—	−$0.8M
Edwin Hurtado	pre-arb	$109K	$0.3M	-1.2	—	−$1.8M
Total over the control window			$0.4M	-1.8	—	−$2.6M

Toronto Blue Jays received

Miguel Cairo2B · 21 · prospect · 6 yrs control+0.0WAR (control) · 1 yr48

Rest of season47WAR0.0wRC+—PA0Surplus$0.0M

Short term49WAR+0.0wRC+57PA30Surplus−$0.2M

Control window48WAR+0.0wRC+57PA30Surplus−$0.2M

Full tenure48WAR+0.0wRC+57PA30Surplus−$0.2M

too little playing time to rate quality

Bill RisleyP · 28 · arb 1 · 3 yrs control-0.3WAR (control) · 3 yr28

Rest of season47WAR0.0FIP−—IP0Surplus$0.0M

Short term58WAR+0.2FIP−117IP42Surplus$0.1M

Control window18WAR-0.3FIP−122IP101Surplus−$1.3M

Full tenure19WAR-0.3FIP−122IP101Surplus−$1.3M

On the day: +1.5 WAR over the prior three seasons, FIP− 77, salary $135K.

Received	Status	Salary that year	Paid	WAR	$/WAR	Surplus
Miguel Cairo	prospect	est.	$0.2M	+0.0	—	−$0.2M
Bill Risley	arb 1	$135K	$1.0M	-0.3	—	−$1.3M
Total over the control window			$1.2M	-0.3	—	−$1.5M

What this became

Miguel Cairo → CHCMiguel Cairo, CHC ⇄ TOR, 1996+0.1 WAR
Paul Menhart → SDPPaul Menhart, SDP ⇄ SEA, 1997+0.2 WAR

The web around this trade

loading the web…

player · size = WAR delivered, colour = percentile ( worse better) franchise trade 0 players · 0 trades · 0 clubs

All SEA ⇄ TOR trades How the scores work