May 4, 1919

George Smith and 2 others: Philadelphia PhilliesSan Francisco Giants

Philadelphia Phillies came out ahead by 3.3 WAR, most of it from George Smith.

Philadelphia Phillies
franchise trade score
90far better
Franchise trade score90
Rest of season73WAR in+0.1WAR out-0.0Net+0.1
Short term91WAR in+2.3WAR out-0.0Net+2.3
Control window91WAR in+3.3WAR out-0.0Net+3.3
Full tenure89WAR in+3.3WAR out-0.0Net+3.3
San Francisco Giants
franchise trade score
10far worse
Franchise trade score10
Rest of season27WAR in-0.0WAR out+0.1Net-0.1
Short term9WAR in-0.0WAR out+2.3Net-2.3
Control window9WAR in-0.0WAR out+3.3Net-3.3
Full tenure11WAR in-0.0WAR out+3.3Net-3.3

Philadelphia Phillies received

George SmithP · 27 · arb 1 · 8 yrs control+4.1WAR (control) · 4 yr81
Rest of season82WAR+0.9FIP−104IP185
Short term82WAR+3.1FIP−101IP434
Control window80WAR+4.1FIP−98IP850
Full tenure79WAR+4.1FIP−98IP850

scored without value

On the day: +0.7 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ -3, FIP− 94, salary $3K.

Ed Sicking2B · 22 · pre-arb · 8 yrs control-0.8WAR (control) · 1 yr4
Rest of season2WAR-0.8wRC+36PA201
Short term3WAR-0.8wRC+36PA201
Control window4WAR-0.8wRC+36PA201
Full tenure4WAR-0.8wRC+36PA201

scored without value

On the day: -0.3 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 73, salary $2K.

San Francisco Giants received

Joe OeschgerP · 27 · arb 3 · 8 yrs control-0.0WAR (control) · 1 yr31
Rest of season19WAR-0.0FIP−87IP8
Short term30WAR-0.0FIP−87IP8
Control window32WAR-0.0FIP−87IP8
Full tenure32WAR-0.0FIP−87IP8

too little playing time to rate quality; scored without value

On the day: +1.9 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ -26, FIP− 114, salary $3K.

What this became

  1. Joe Oeschger → ATLArt Nehf, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1919+5.4 WAR
  2. George Smith → LADClarence Mitchell, LAD ⇄ PHI, 1923+0.2 WAR
  3. Joe Oeschger → SFGDave Bancroft, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1923+0.0 WAR
  4. Mickey O'Neil → LADEddie Brown, ATL ⇄ LAD, 1925-0.5 WAR
  5. Billy Southworth → STLBilly Southworth, SFG ⇄ STL, 1926+3.7 WAR
  6. Zack Taylor → SFGLarry Benton, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1927-0.4 WAR
  7. Doc Farrell → SFGJimmy Welsh, ATL ⇄ SFG, 1929-1.3 WAR
  8. Larry Benton → CINLarry Benton, CIN ⇄ SFG, 1930+5.0 WAR

The web around this trade

loading the web…
player · size = WAR delivered, colour = percentile ( worse better) franchise trade 0 players · 0 trades · 0 clubs
All PHI ⇄ SFG tradesHow the scores work