October 7, 1958

Ernie Broglio and 4 others: San Francisco GiantsSt. Louis Cardinals

St. Louis Cardinals got 16.4 WAR out of Ernie Broglio over 6 seasons. San Francisco Giants got 1.8 from the whole return.

San Francisco Giants
franchise trade score
11far worse
Franchise trade score11
Rest of season50WAR in0.0WAR out0.0Net0.0
Short term62WAR in+1.3WAR out+1.2Net+0.1
Control window2WAR in+1.8WAR out+16.2Net-14.5
Full tenure2WAR in+1.8WAR out+16.2Net-14.5
St. Louis Cardinals
franchise trade score
89far better
Franchise trade score89
Rest of season50WAR in0.0WAR out0.0Net0.0
Short term38WAR in+1.2WAR out+1.3Net-0.1
Control window98WAR in+16.2WAR out+1.8Net+14.5
Full tenure98WAR in+16.2WAR out+1.8Net+14.5

STL won the World Series in 1964

San Francisco Giants received

Billy MuffettP · 28 · pre-arb · 8 yrs control-0.2WAR (control) · 1 yr21
Rest of season45WAR0.0FIP−—IP0
Short term20WAR-0.2FIP−180IP7
Control window21WAR-0.2FIP−180IP7
Full tenure22WAR-0.2FIP−180IP7

too little playing time to rate quality; scored without value

On the day: +3.4 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ -100, FIP− 69.

Hobie LandrithC · 28 · FA eligible · 8 yrs control+1.9WAR (control) · 3 yr71
Rest of season45WAR0.0wRC+—PA0
Short term72WAR+1.5wRC+84PA335
Control window71WAR+1.9wRC+83PA641
Full tenure70WAR+1.9wRC+83PA641

scored without value

On the day: +0.1 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 71.

Benny Valenzuela3B · 25 · pre-arb · 8 yrs control0.0WAR (control)40
Rest of season45WAR0.0wRC+—PA0
Short term41WAR0.0wRC+—PA0
Control window40WAR0.0wRC+—PA0
Full tenure40WAR0.0wRC+—PA0

never reached the majors for SFG; scored without value

St. Louis Cardinals received

Marv GrissomP · 40 · FA eligible · 8 yrs control-0.2WAR (control) · 1 yr19
Rest of season45WAR0.0FIP−—IP0
Short term18WAR-0.2FIP−375IP2
Control window19WAR-0.2FIP−375IP2
Full tenure19WAR-0.2FIP−375IP2

too little playing time to rate quality; scored without value

On the day: +5.4 WAR over the prior three seasons, wRC+ 31, FIP− 81.

Ernie BroglioP · 23 · prospect · 8 yrs control+16.4WAR (control) · 6 yr85
Rest of season45WAR0.0FIP−—IP0
Short term78WAR+1.4FIP−98IP181
Control window89WAR+16.4FIP−96IP1124
Full tenure89WAR+16.4FIP−96IP1124

scored without value

What this became

  1. Billy Muffett → BOSBilly Muffett, BOS ⇄ SFG, 1959+2.8 WAR
  2. Ernie Broglio → CHCLou Brock, CHC ⇄ STL, 1964-0.9 WAR
  3. Doug Clemens → PHIDoug Clemens, CHC ⇄ PHI, 1966+0.1 WAR

The web around this trade

loading the web…
player · size = WAR delivered, colour = percentile ( worse better) franchise trade 0 players · 0 trades · 0 clubs
All SFG ⇄ STL tradesHow the scores work